Sometimes the places that become the most important to us are the ones we never planned to visit.
That is exactly how Door County, Wisconsin came into our lives.
Back in September 2011, we had just gotten married. Newlyweds, already parents to our almost-four-year-old daughter, we wanted to grow our family and knew we didn’t have the time or money to take a honeymoon somewhere out of the country! My co-worker at the time had grown up going to Door County and recommended that we do a mini honeymoon there.
Prior to that discussion, Door County wasn’t even on our radar!
We took her advice and booked the Beach House in Fish Creek and headed north for what was supposed to be a little mini honeymoon. Looking back, it is pretty amazing to think that we had no idea what we were about to discover.
At the time, the Beach House felt like the perfect place for us. It had water views, was walkable to so many things in Fish Creek, and right next door to Blue Horse Café – which is still one of our favorites to this day.
A Different Time
Although it was only 15 years ago, Door County has changed quite a bit since then. There were far fewer choices for restaurants, shops and places to stay, and September felt much quieter than it does today. A lot of places were already closed for the season or had very limited hours. I remember joking that if we didn’t eat by 5:00 pm, we might be out of luck.
One night, we had dinner at Summertime, which is now home to Barringers. It felt like we might have been the only people in the restaurant. And in true fashion, we somehow ended up talking with the owner, Terry Bolland for quite some time. We had a great conversation and he generously shared so much of the area history with us – which we are still grateful for today!
Door County Classics
For our very first visit, we managed to squeeze in quite a bit. We visited Peninsula State Park and climbed the second iteration of the Eagle Tower. Today, Eagle Tower is in it’s third iteration and is a pretty impressive structure that’s hard to miss. However, when we first visited, the tower was much simpler—a roughly 75-foot-tall wooden structure that seemed to stretch straight into the sky. And there was only one way to see the view: 108 stairs up and down.
We explored Eagle Bluff Lighthouse, visited Cana Island, and spent time at Pebble Beach.
We had heard you can’t visit Door County for the first time without seeing the goats on the roof, so we headed to Al Johnson’s in Sister Bay. At that time Stabbur Beer Garden wasn’t even an idea!
We had a famous fish boil and even checked out the ferry – which is a bit ironic that it’s just down the road from our cottages today!
We Didn’t Know It Then
There’s no way we could have known just how much Door County would eventually become such a huge part of our lives. That first trip was supposed to be a mini honeymoon. A quick weekend getaway. A chance to celebrate getting married, spend some time together and explore somewhere neither of us really knew.
Instead, Door County stuck with us. We came home with memories, favorite places and a growing appreciation for the beauty of the peninsula. But we certainly didn’t come home thinking: “Someday we will own our own place there.” And we definitely didn’t think three vacation cottages were possible.
That part came much later. Our first trip was simply the beginning. Over the years, we kept coming back. In fact, that co-worker is a lifelong friend and in 2014 her parents (who are also like family to us) purchased a second home in Sister Bay. Each summer they allowed us to take our kids to enjoy all that Door County has to offer and it turned out that they loved it just as much as we did!
Over the years we discovered more of the peninsula, found places that became traditions, experienced Door County in different seasons and eventually fell pretty hard for Northern Door County.
Years later, we found ourselves looking for a cottage of our own. That search wasn’t easy, but eventually led us to The Birch. And then along came maybe the most unexpected turn – The Cedar and The Spruce.
But that’s another story for another time.
From Mini Honeymoon to Timberline Cottages
If our friend hadn’t suggested Door County back in 2011, we might never have taken that first trip. If we hadn’t wandered around the peninsula checking off those first iconic Door County stops, we might not have fallen in love with the place. And if we hadn’t kept coming back, we certainly wouldn’t be where we are today.
What started as an affordable mini honeymoon in Door County quickly became a place that we fell in love with and now feels a lot like home (but better)?
Today, we have the privilege of sharing three little cottages in Northern Door County with families, couples, friends and four-legged guests who are looking for their own escape. We often wonder what would have happened if our friend hadn’t said those five words:
“You should go to Door County.”
We’re pretty glad we listened. And if you’re planning your first trip to Door County, we hope you discover a few places that become part of your story, too. Because sometimes the best places aren’t the ones you plan to find – sometimes, you just stumble upon them.











